Overall Draft Grade: A-
Overall I liked the draft, mostly because of DeVonta smith
and because of the potential of Landon Dickerson. I was surprised the Eagles
took Smith instead of reaching for a third round projected WR who has bad
hands, but sometimes they get it right. The Eagles desperately needed CBs and
got a possible player in the 4th. They also addressed the D-line
with some potential. As always the Eagles don’t value linebackers even though they
are very important to the defense. They drafted two late, which probably won’t
make the team.
Round 1:
DeVonta Smith, WR 6’0 170
Grade: A+
DeVonta
Smith is one of the best route runners in college football. He also has great
hands. He’s basically the opposite of Jalen Reagor from last year. I hated that
pick since I wanted Justin Jefferson, WR instead. I made it very clear last
year. Jalen Reagor is fast, but otherwise isn’t a good route runner and has bad
hands. Devonta was very productive in college partly because Waddle went down
with an injury. Devonta had 3965 yards for his career with a 16.9 yard average. He
also had 46 TDs. His 117 catches and 1856 yards won him the Heisman his senior
year. His only issue is his size, but DeSean Jackson did very well in the NFL
with a similar weight. DeVonta has much better stats in college than DeSean
had. The Eagles finally have their number one receiver.
Round 2
Landon Dickerson, C 6’6 333
Grade: B
Landon’s
biggest concern is his injury history. He has had multiple season-ending
injuries. If he manages not to get injured, though, he has great size and strength.
Although he has shorter than desired arms, he is good with his hand fighting
and initial punch. We don’t have any measurable on Landon. As long as injuries
aren’t a problem Landon should be a good pick. The Eagles needed depth at guard
and will need a new center possibly next year since Kelce is getting close to
retirement. If he doesn’t get injured often he’s probably an A.
Round 3:
Milton Williams, DT 6’3 284
Grade: B+
Milton is
small for DT at 284 pounds. He also has shorter than desired arms. That being
said he is measurably the most athletic DT ever including Aaron Donald. He ran
a 4.67 40, had a 38.5 inch vertical, a 10 foot broad jump, ran a 6.96 3 cone,
and a 4.33 shuttle. He’d even be athletic for a TE. He had decent stats where
over two years he had 104 tackles, 19 tackles for a loss, and 10 sacks. All are
good numbers for a DT. He needs to improve his pass rushing techniques and get
bigger if he wants to play DT in the NFL. He could possibly play DE with some
work on his pass rushing. Also, he could come in during pass rush situations as
DT if he improves. Although he is lighter, he doesn’t have much fat like most DTs.
Round 4:
Zech McPhearson, CB
Grade: B
Zech has
some potential with his decent speed and good ball skills. He doesn’t have
great route recognition and has a bumpy backpedal. His 6.88 cone and 4.00
shuttle, combined with his 40.5 inch vertical and 10.8 inch broad jump show
that he has potential. His 4.48 40 isn’t as great as I’d like to see, however. Statistically, he did okay. He did have 104 tackles in two years. But only 11 passes broken up
in two years. He did however have 4 ints his senior year, which is impressive.
He’s not a bad selection in the 4th round. I would rather have
drafted Robert Rochell, CB.
Round 5:
Kenneth Gainwell, RB 5’8 201
Grade: A
Kenneth is a
little light, but it’s not really a concern since he’s 5’8. He did have a good
senior year with 1459 yards a 6.3 yard average and 600 receiving yards with a
12 yard average which is great. He didn’t have much production his other years.
He ran a solid 4.42 in the 40 and has above average reps in the bench. Unfortunately,
he didn’t have other measurable. I like to ensure that a RB’s cone is under 7.
He’s good at reading blocks and has decent lateral movement. He’s more of a one-cut runner than someone who can juke laterally multiple times like LeSean McCoy
could. He’s not much of an inside runner, but he’s okay in pass blocking and
could become a third down back. He looks explosive on tape and showed a nice
spin move, but he isn’t very powerful. For the 5th round he’s a very
good pick.
Round 6:
Marlong Tuipulotu, DT 6’2 307
Grade: B
Marlong is
basically the opposite of Milton Williams. He’s not particularly athletic. He
ran a 7.57 cone, a 4.69 shuttle, and an average 8’7 inch broad jump. He only
played 5 games his senior year, and has average statistics for his other years.
He’s not particularly impressive production wise. He does have much better size
than Marlong though, but is kind of short for a DT. He has good hands, and is
known to be tough but wears down as the game goes on. He looks okay and could
become a backup at DT.
Round 6:
Tarron Jackson, DE 6’2 254
Grade: C+
Tarron is a
little small at 254 and doesn’t have very good length. He is very strong though
and has some nice pass rush moves. He’s not very explosive though and not great
at changing direction. He’s from a smaller school, but has good stats. He has
42 tackles for a loss in 4 years, 188 tackles, and 24.5 sacks. His measurable are
not great for his size though and is probably not athletic enough to play in
the NFL.
Round 6:
JaCoby Stevens, LB 6’1 212
Grade: B-
JaCoby is
too small to play LB and not athletic enough to play Safety. He has below
average speed for safety and doesn’t have the athleticism for coverage. He’d
have to put on 20 or 30 lbs of muscle to make it as a LB. He was decent statistically
with 190 tackles, 21.5 for a loss and 9.5 sacks in three years. He also had 4
picks and 15 passes broken up in 3 years. He has an impressive 42 inch vertical
and 10’8 foot broad jump. If he can maintain those numbers and his 40 of 4.63
as he puts on weight, he has some potential.
Round 7:
Patrick Johnson, LB 6’2 240
Grade: A
Patrick has
good size to play LB, unlike JaCoby. He was a DE pass rusher in college, but
unless he puts on 20 lbs he’s going to have to move to LB. He has some good
moves in the pass rusher and is good at shedding blockers, but in the pass rush
he has below average burst. Statistically, he did pretty well with 34 tackles for
a loss in three years, and 21 sacks. He didn’t have many tackles. He also had 6
forced fumbles and 11 passes broken up. Athletically he’s decent with a 4.59
40, a 35 inch vertical, and a 6.97 3 cone. I like the potential he has for a 7th
round pick.