Eagles Rookie Free Agent Signings and Grades

Free Agent Signings Grades and Analysis 

Overall Rookie Free Agent Singing Grade: A

We signed some solid players that can make the team and even start at some point.

Corey Clement RB 5’’11 220: A

Corey has potential. He didn’t have a great rushing average his senior year, but did during his freshman and sophomore years. He has poor long speed but is shifty enough for a bigger guy and has above average acceleration. He also shows some power during his runs. He didn’t catch the ball much, but does well when he catches it. He really looks like someone who could not only make the team, but could become a contributor in the run game.  

Greg Ward Jr. WR: F

Greg played QB in college, but switched to WR during the draft process. He is simply not athletic enough to play WR.

Tre Sullivan FS: F

Too small and not athletic enough for the NFL.

Tyler Orlosky C: C+

Not athletic, but he is strong and was a team captain. He does have some potential, but his short arms and lack of athleticism, will likely limit him to not making the team.

Billy Brown TE: A

Billy has good size at 6’3, 254 and has the athleticism to play in the NFL. He alos had a huge senior year with over 1500 yards and 22 TDs. He also had a huge junior year with almost 1500 yards and 10 touchdowns. He had a 16.3 yard average during those two years. He has good hands, but will need to work on his routes. While he doesn’t have elite long speed for WR, (his position in college) he does have decent top speed for a TE. What can I say about this guy but he will likely make the team and has a chance to become a future starter for the Eagles.

Marcus Oliver ILB 5’11 238: B

Marcus is a powerful and productive inside linebacker. He is a good tackler and forced many fumbles in college. He lacks athleticism to the outside and in coverage, and he is poor at changing directions. That being said, Marcus has the chance to be a first and second down linebacker in run situations and could make the team as a backup.

Jomal Wiltz CB  5’10 174: A-

Wiltz had a good number of passes broken up during his two years of college. He is small and will have to put on some weight, but he is athletic enough to cover NFL WRs. He could make the team and could even be better than the Eagles third round pick Rasul.  

Winston Craig DT 6’3 288: B-

Not a bad free agent pick up. He is small for DT but big enough that he could come in on passing downs. He has average athleticism for his size and above average production in college. He played at a small school though and usually you would want a player to dominate at that level if they are going to make an NFL team. He has some potential. 

Philadelphia Eagles Draft Grade and Assessment

Eagles Draft Grade

Overall Grade: B- : We didn't get many if any players that will come right in and start. I don't think Barnett is ready and Sidney Jones is injured. Rasul will likely never start. We did however get some nice athletic developmental prospects that could eventually contribute and Sidney Jones looks like he will be good when he heals. Derek could become a passable starter as well.

Round 1: Derek Barnett DE: B-

It’s not like Barnett doesn’t have positives or that he can’t become a very good player, it’s just that he doesn’t look like a sure thing like other players did. Yes, he was very productive and even broke Reggie White’s record. Does that make him Reggie White? No. Reggie had forty pounds on Barnett. He was quicker, better at changing direction, and more powerful than Barnett.

Barnett is great at fighting with his hands, but his arms are very short and 3 inches shorter than miles Garrett. He is decent against the run, but his change of direction speed and closing speed are liabilities. He was productive, it seems, largely due to his hand fighting and his anticipation of the snap. He will have a much harder time doing the same things in the NFL. His anticipation of the snap helped mask his explosion off of the line, which was average at best. Barnett could become a reliable starter if he increases his pass rushing skill set, but he is not a sure thing. I would love a dominant DE and have been waiting for one for a long time. I hope that Barnett becomes the man for us, and he could, but I would have gone a safer direction here.

Round 2: Sidney Jones CB 6’0 186: B

Sidney was projected to be a first round pick until he tore his Achilles tendon. He has enough athletic ability to stay with WR except for fast receivers on deep routes. He has natural talent and awareness at the position to overcome his sub elite athletics. His production was pretty good in college, but he didn’t have any amazing years. He has good hands and can pull in interceptions. Sidney is a hard pick to grade. He could develop into a good CB. His injury is a setback, but also helped the Eagles to get him in the second round. The value and injury cancel out on the grade. Other than that he has enough potential for a B grade.

Round 3: Douglas Rasul CB 6’2 209: D+

Rasul has great size for a press CB. He could also play safety. He is a one year wonder in college which is concerning. It was quite a good year with 8 ints, but it’s always risky relying on one year. He does not have a great long speed at 4.6 which is a concern as a CB. He also only have average athletics otherwise. Because of his poor long speed, he will need safety help over the top, and he will have to give a strong jam at the line. He is likely a better safety than CB athletically, but since he’s not a great tackler that limits his potential move. He will have problems staying with WRs on all routes.

Round 4: Mack Hollins WR 6’4 221: B

Mack has great size for a WR. Ideal really. He only ran the 40 at the combine and had a solid 4.5. While he doesn’t have another measrualbes, he is very quick and has great acceleration. He needs to greatly improve his route running on shorter routes to be able to get open. He also needs to work on his catching ability and stop body catching. He certainly has potential to become a top WR if he gets everything else together. He wasn’t very productive in college, which is a little concerning, but once again he has good potential.

Round 4: Donnel Pumphrey RB: B-

He could only be used for a return man. He’s too small to pass block so he can’t be in on third downs. He’s too small to play RB on first and second downs. If his hands weren’t bellow average, he could play WR on some special plays. He doesn’t have long speed, but he does accelerate very quickly. He also has good lateral agility, not the two man cutting ability of Lesean Mccoy, but good. His production was huge in college… tons of yards, tons of tds, good average. If he can put on 20 lbs and learn to pass block, he could be a great third down RB and maybe contribute on first and second downs. If he weighed 25 lbs more and still had the same quickness, he would have been an A pick in the 4^th. Many small players like him cannot make the jump to the NFL though. That being said, I want him to make it. If he gets bigger it looks like he could be special.

Round 5: Shelton Gibson WR 5’11 191: A-

Shelton is a great deep threat with a very good average per catch. He needs to work on his route running and his hands, but if he can get that together, he could be a good wr. He also has good size for someone as fast as he is. People have been comparing him to Desean Jackson. He is similar, but not the same. He’s bigger than him and not quite as fast as him. I love the pick in the 5^th round.

Round 5: Nate Gerry S 6’2 218: C-

Nate is simply not athletic enough to play safety in the NFL. It’s possible that he could put on weight and play LB. He was decently productive in college. He has good ball skills with 13 ints. He isn’t good enough with coverage to cover WRs. He could cover TEs though. He missed many tackles in college, so he would have to improve there.

Round 6: Elijah Qualls DT 6’1 313: B

Elijah has power and can attack low with good leverage. He has very short arms though, the second shortest of all D lineman. He also has decent athleticism. His production is average in college and he needs to get into better shape. The two biggest concerns about him are his arm length and his work ethic. For the 6^th round it’s not bad to change a chance on someone who has some potential.

Philadelphia Eagles Mock Draft 2017

Eagles Mock Draft

1st Round: Marlon Humphrey CB, or Ryan Ramczyk OT since we need a future RT and I'm not feeling the other prospects. We could go CB in round two if we went OT here. (I'm not into Derek Barnett, the projected pick in some mocks) - If Marlon is around at the Eagles pick he will be very worth drafting and will likely become a starter.

2nd Round: Dion Dawkins OT - We need depth at tackle for when someone gets injured and when Jason Peters Retires. Dion has power in the run game and also adequate athleticism to pass block. He could move in at RT after Peters retires and Lane Johnson moves to LT.  

3rd Round: Taywan Taylor WR - We don't need a WR as much as we did before signing Alshon Jeffery but Taywan has a ton of potential. 

4th Round: Shaquill Griffin CB - A very athletic CB with good coverage ability. His top speed isn't elite, but he can develop into a very good CB. 

4th Round:  Marlin Mack RB - Marlin is a speedy productive RB. He has great acceleration once he picks his lane. He has the potential to compete for the top Eagles RB spot. 

5th Round: Connor Harris ILB - Connor is a small school prospect who was a tackle machine. Not all players can make the jump from a small school to the NFL, but Connor has the athleticism and drive to be one of them. 

6th Round: Robert Davis WR - An excellent sized WR with good explosion. His routes need work but he has great hands and is great at high pointing the ball. He will provide us even more depth at WR for a strong camp competition. 

7th Round:7 Joe Williams RB - Joe has great acceleration and finds holes quickly. He has a great rushing average in college and looked great on tape. He does have several character issues, but if he is committed to the game, Joe could be a starting running back.

Best Middle and Late Round Draft Prospects

Late and Middle Round Draft Prospects

RB

Joe Williams - Joe is great through the hole with top acceleration. He finds the holes quick without dancing around and has good top speed. He had a 6.7 yard average during his senior year and good measurables. He looks really great on tape, and should be a good starting running back barring problems from his character. He retired from football for two months and has an arrest record. He will need to be interviewed well to determine his dedication to the sport. CBS round projection 6,7

T.J. Logan - He is fast and eats up ground quick with long strides. He has good but not great later agility. He is more of a one cut and go runner. He looks like he could be a strong third down back if he can improve his pass blocking. He should put on some muscle since he doesn't have that much power and a smaller lower body. CBS round projection 5,6. 

Justin Davis - He has good acceleration through his cuts and can make some good moves. He has quick feet and quick cuts. He is also a good pass catcher. His measurables are acceptable, and his 3 cone is good. He should put on some weight, but otherwise looks like he could be worthwhile pick, possibly as a 3rd down back. CBS round projection RFA

WR

Taywan Taylor - Hes a mid round prospect. He has a ton of potential. His top speed isn't amazing, but he is very quick and still got open on deep balls quite a bit. He looks very open on many of his catches. He only ran a few routes, so he will need more practice, but he should become a starting second receiver or slot receiver. CBS round projection 3,4

Robert Davis - He has very good size and very good measurables, especially his vertical and broad jumps, which shows explosion. He had good stats but nothing amazing. His routes need work but he has great hands and is great at high pointing the ball. If he can improve his route running, he could become a starting receiver in the NFL. CBS round projection 6

TE

Bucky Hodges - He has both great athletics and great statistics. He looks like a sure thing as a receiving TE. He's another mid round prospect projected to go in the 4th round. I included him because he just looks great. Even if a team doesn't need a TE, he would be a steal in the 4th round. He could learn from the starter and be the eventual starter. He need to improve his route running for sure though and work on his hands a bit. 

DT

Grover Stewart - He's a 347lbs NT. He is athletic for his size and is super strong. He needs to work on his technique and his pad level, but if he can consistently attack with lower pads, he could become a force to be reckoned with. He had good production for a man of his size, but it was at lower level competition. He will need to make a big jump to the NFL. Since he's a 6th round projected prospect, he's worth pulling the trigger on. 

CB

Shaquill Griffin - He's very athletic, but his top speed isn't elite. He has good coverage and hardly allowed any passes to be completed. He also has many passes broken up. He might have to play the slot or in the cover 2, but he looks like he can develop into a very good CB. He's also a mid round prospect with a projected round of 3.

Ahkello Witherspoon - He has good height and very good athletics. He has many passes broken up and very few passes completed. He doesn't get many interceptions and needs to get a little stronger as well. He's projected to go in the third round. 

FS

Branden Leston - He has great athletics and good size. His stats are also good with 90+ tackles for two years and 9 passes broken up his senior year. He's worth definitely pick up since he's projected as a RFA. He has the potential to become a starter.

Jason Thompson - He barely played football and started out as a QB. He is incredibly athletic though and should be taken as a RFA to see if he can be developed into a FS or SS.

Eagles Rookie Free Agent Signing Analysis

Eagles Rookie Free Agent Signing Analysis:

Best Defensive Signing:

Destiny Vaeao, DT – he had an okay senior year with 40 tackles, 12 for a loss, and 4.5 sacks. He

didn’t do much any other year. He is also athletic enough and strong enough to play the position. He is quick off of the snap and has a good pad level. Vaeao has a decent shot to make the team and contribute.

Best Offensive Signing:

Bruce Johnson, C – Johnson is probably athletic enough to play the position and tested well at the combine. He started his entire senior year at center and his offensive line was fifth in rushing offense and second in passing offense in 2014. The offense struggled in 2015, but Johnson still did a good job. He was given the Rimington Award as the best center in the FCS. He very well might make the team. He also has long arms at 33.50 which are the second longest for any center.

Other Singings:

Aziz Shittu, DE – Not strong enough to play DT at this point unless he comes in on third down in obvious pass situations. He also isn’t athletic enough to play end.  He does have long arms and some agility. He didn’t really come on until his senior year, but he had a decent year playing 60 percent of the time. He has a chance to make the team.

Connor Wujciak, DE – Needs to get stronger and will have to play DT. He has short arms, and comes off the snap high. He is pretty athletic but doesn’t explode off the line. Poor stats for his career, but did test well at the combine. He looks unimpressive on tape. He probably wont make the team.

Byron Marshall, RB – Looks very similar to Kenjon Barner and Wendell Smallwood, but he doesn’t look quite as good at cutting as Kenjon. He catches the ball well and went for over 1000 yards his junior year. He also rushed for 1877 yards and a 6.1 yard average during his career. It looks like he will be as likely as Smallwood to make the team, but smallwood does have a faster top speed. I’m still a bigger fan of KenJon Barner. He looks like he’s better than Smallwood and Marshall at this point. We should have drafted Jonathan Williams instead.

Hunter Sharp, WR – Doesn’t seem athletic enough to play WR in the nfl based on his measurable, but looks better on tape. His stats are mediocre. He’s also a body catcher and has some character issues. He will likely not make the team.

Quentin Gause, LB – His stats are not that impressive but he does have a lot of solo tackles. He has a few tackles for losses, but hardly any sacks or passes broken up. He tested well at the combine and had an excellent shuttle and cone. Made some nice plays on tape and has some speed. I’m concerned about his coverage ability because of the limited pbu. He does have a chance to make the team as a backup and special teamer.

C.J. Smith, CB – He comes from a small school, the same one as Carson Wentz. He had a good senior season with 16 passes broken up and 4 interceptions. His is probably not athletic enough to play cornerback and he isn’t big enough to play safety unless he puts on 20 lbs.  He definitely has hand skills though and has a shot to make the team.

Cedric O’Neal, RB – He had a thousand yards and a six yard average during his senior year. His measurable are at the lower acceptable level. He pretty good feet and can juke guys out with his lean. He isn’t super agile though. He has a little more power than Smallwood and Marshall, but nothing to write home about. He probably will not make the team.

Myke Tavarres, LB – He had excellent stats his senior year with 110 tackles 22.5 for a loss and 8.5 sacks. He didn’t test very well at the combine though and only weights 230 lbs. He ran a 4.8 40 and a 4.51 shuttle. Both are very poor numbers. He looks quicker than he tested on tape though. He has a shot to make the team.

Marcus Johnson, WR – He has very poor production and while his 40 time, verticals and broad jump are all very good. His shuttle and cone are bad. There is no tape, but he seems like a straight ahead guy who will have trouble cutting fast enough in his routes to get open. He will probably not make the team.

Eagles NFL Draft Grade

Eagles Overall Draft Grade: C Because of trade. (If we had these picks and didn’t trade it would be a B)

Carson wentz, QB- If we had the number two pick in the first place and wanted to make this pick it

would be a B. If we factor in the many picks that we gave up to trade up, then the pick would be a D. The reason the pick gets a D is because we already had two capable QBs. It doesn’t make sense to sign Bradford and Daniels to huge contracts if we didn’t have faith in them. If we were going to trade up we should not have signed Bradford.

Carson has potential. He is big, has a strong arm, and goes through his progressions well. He is athletic, but not super athletic. He played in the former 1AA level, which is below the top level of football. He also only started a year and a half. He could work out and if he does, it will be a good move. The odds of it working out are probably forty percent. If it doesn’t work out we will be hard pressed to be a good team since we lost so many draft picks.

Grade: B, if we didn’t trade up. Grade: D, since we traded up.

Isaac Seumalo, G – I like Isaac a lot. I hoped that we would be able to get him later in the draft though since he was originally projected to go in the 5th. He is one of the more athletic guards. He needs to get a little stronger, but otherwise he has good potential to start at guard in the near future. He could potential play tackle also since he has good feet and is athletic. He’s a little shorter than a lot of OTs, but he has good arm length.

Grade: A-

Wendell Smallwood, RB – On first inspection Wendell seems like he could be a good running back. He had 1,519 rushing yards and a 6.4 yard average. He also caught the ball well during his career and had 618 receiving yards in three years. He also has good measurable. A 4.42 and a 6.83 3cone. His other numbers are reasonable, but not great. Everything looks good until you put on his tape. He is a one speed player. If a hole is there he can go through it and he is reasonably fast. He doesn’t seem like a 4.4 player though. He isn’t very explosive through the hole either. He doesn’t have power and his lateral agility isn’t that impressive for being a smaller guy. He simply isn’t that impressive. He is pretty much the same running back as Kenjon Barner (the Eagles third RB), but he isn’t as fast or explosive and doesn’t cut as well. The Eagles missed out on DeAndre Washington earlier in the round which isn’t their fault, but Jonathan Williams was still available. He is better at cutting and quicker feet even though he weights 12 more pounds. He is more explosive and way more powerful. He doesn’t have the same top speed, but he will be a much better running back. Alex Collins was also a better back that was still available. Lastly, if we were going to take a running back that isn’t good, we should have taken Kentrell Brothers ILB.

Grade: D -

Halapoulivaati Vaitai, OT – I’m really wary about Halapoulivaati. He is big at 320 6’6, and he benches well, but he doesn’t have the core strength needed to play guard at this time. He could develop it so he has a chance to be a good Guard. He doesn’t seem to be athletic enough to play tackle and will get beat by speed rushers. There were times that he got destroyed by speed. His feet aren’t good enough to play tackle. He also plays with too high pad level, which will give him problems with bull rushers. He is taller than preferred to play guard, but it seems like he’s going to have to play guard. Lastly, he doesn’t get much push in the run game. He has potential, but I would have chosen Mortiz Boehringer WR or Elandon Roberts ILB.

Grade: C-

Blake Contess, CB – He has some potential. He seems to be athletic enough based on his measurable. His statistics are reasonable also. He is light though at 184 and isn’t great in run support since he takes bad angles and is weak. He will probably have to play nickel corner. If we didn’t trade up to take Wentz, I would have taken Brandon Allen QB here. We could have also considered Mitch Mathews WR or James Cowser LB.

Grade: B-

Jalen Mills, FS – He is athletic enough for Safety or even corner back. He has good size at 6 foot, but if he is going to play safety he should bulk up from his current 191 weight. He adds depth and has potential to be a slot corner back. He could play safety if he gets bigger and gets better against the run. For a seventh round pick he isn’t bad. We could have considered Dwayne Washington RB, or Aaron Green RB or James Cowser LB, or Tyler Matakevich LB here.

Grade: B+

Alex McCalister, DE – He has potential. He shows ability to rush the passer. He is much too small though to play DE right now. He needs to put on 20 lbs at least. He is athletic and could probably bulk up and keep his speed. He is a project with some upside. He had pretty good statistics for being a part time rusher. He simply needs to get much bigger and stronger. He also has some character concerns according to NFL.com I don’t hate the pick but once again I would have probably taken We could have considered Aaron Green RB, James Cowser LB, Scooby Wright III, or Tyler Matakevich LB here.

Grade: B+

Joe Walker, ILB – Joe has potential. He is athletic enough to play linebacker in the NFL. He has reasonable statistics, but nothing that impressive. On tape he seems to be athletic enough, but he takes bad angles and is fooled by jukes. He doesn’t seem that impressive on tape but there is limited tape. He has some potential for a 7^th round pick. I would have considered Aaron Green RB, Brandon Burks RB, James Cowser LB, Justin Zimmer DT, or Beau Sandland TE here.

Grade: B

Top Wide Receivers in 2016 NFL draft

Top Wide Receivers in 2016 NFL draft

      1. Corey Coleman, Baylor – Coleman has elite athleticism, and is really great after the catch. The first

tackler only gets him 34% of the time. He scored the most touchdowns compared to the other top prospects. He’s good against contested catches. Overall, he has good hands, but he does drop the ball 8.6% of the time.

           2.  Josh Doctson, TCU – He has top level hands and ability to catch. He caught 74.7% of his targets which is 10% better than anyone else.  He has very good athleticism, second only to Coleman. He doesn’t have deep speed like Fuller and Coleman, but he does have short area quickness. He is good when double covered and good versus contested catches. He also doesn’t drop many balls. He had the second best statistical year with a 17 yard average and 1326 yards during his senior year even though he was injured part of it.

     3. Leonte Carroo, Rutgers – I like him a little better than Tredwell because he catches a high percentage of balls and drops less catchable balls. He also had a much longer average than Tredwell and is more athletic. He has some possible behavior flags though.

           4. Laquon Tredwell, Ole Miss– Not very athtlic and not that amazing statistics. He also only caught fifty percent of his targets. He has a long reach and makes some hard catches look easy though. He is good after the catch and good at catching contested balls. If he can catch a higher percentage, he can be very good.

      5. Tyler Boyd, PITT – He has good long speed and decent athleticism. He isn’t great versus contested catches and tends to go down easily in space. He does catch a high percentage of balls though. His senior average wasn’t good at 10.2, but his career numbers are better. he can also run the ball well.

            6. Will Fuller, Notre Dame – Top level speed. Very fast over the top. Not as quick in short spaces as Coleman though. He has problems with drops and doesn’t catch a high percentage of balls. He has small hands and doesn’t weight very much at 186lbs. He could be a good deep threat, but his catching issues could limit him. It seems like people are overrating him based on his 40 time.

           7.Sterling Shepard, Oklahoma – Gets pushed around some, but catches a high percentage of balls and doesn’t drop many of them. He’s also good when doubled, but not as good with contested catches. He’s shifty in space, but not an elite athlete.